News / Member Insight / Business operations

Nervous About October? Understanding what a Tronc council really means for your business

Most operators we speak to are nervous about October. They’re right to be.

The next phase of the Employment Rights Act is coming in, bringing with it further requirements around tipping and Tronc in the UK. The final results of a major hospitality tipping tribunal appeal, due to be heard later this year, are likely to sharpen the stakes further. For operators already navigating the Allocation of Tips Act 2023, they will now need to factor in employee consultations when it comes to their tipping policy and practices.

What’s already in force, and what’s coming:

Since October 2024, the Allocation of Tips Act has required employers to operate a written tipping policy and provide a written summary of tips received and allocated to any worker who asks for one. Tips must be distributed fairly, and the policy must be readily available to all staff.

The Employment Rights Act 2025 adds another layer, expected from October 2026. Employers will be required to consult with workers, or their representatives, before creating or changing a tipping policy, and to review that policy at least every three years. Tribunal time limits are also expected to double from three months to six months, meaning staff will have twice as long to bring a claim if something goes wrong.

One way to approach the upcoming need for worker consultations is to establish a Tronc council, a panel of staff from different departments or teams in your business that represent your employees as a whole, and help shape decisions when it comes to the Tronc policy.

What is a Tronc Council?

A Tronc council is a group of representative workers who help decide how tips, gratuities and service charges are distributed. It sits alongside a written tip policy and an independent Troncmaster, who designs the framework and makes the final call. These would form worker representatives you must consult with come October of this year.

Independence when it comes to this Tronc council is key. Representatives should be staff chosen by the employees and should receive tips themselves, not employers or upper management. If HMRC concludes that an employer has influenced Tronc decisions, NIC exemption can be revoked, and the business can be liable for back-payments and staff compensation. Senior leaders who try to steer council discussions put the whole arrangement at risk. It is also worth noting that a Tronc council will generally incur higher operational costs for the business than other consultation routes, given the structure and ongoing involvement required to run one properly, though this will not be the case in every situation.

Is this the only option?

In short, no. The proposal to Make Work Pay states that when the tipping policy is being created or amended, employers must consult with the representatives of recognised trade unions or worker representatives, or, where there are no such representatives in place, workers likely to be affected by the policy.

While a well-run Tronc Council is one effective route, consulting directly with all affected workers is equally valid under the legislation, and for many operators, it is the stronger choice. Every worker has a direct voice, responses are gathered individually, anonymised and summarised, and the entire process can be run by an independent Troncmaster with the same audit trail and NIC protection. Good Tronc software solutions can automate the whole process, from consultation distribution to response collection, anonymisation, and summary generation. This makes direct consultation a practical and scalable option for businesses of any size. If your employees have trade union representatives, they could also be consulted.

The most important thing is that consultations are fair, transparent, and unbiased. Employees must also receive an anonymised summary of feedback after consultations have taken place, no matter what way these consultations take place.

The multi-site challenge

Multi-site operators face their own challenge. Tips cannot be pooled across sites. Under the Allocation of Tips Act, each site’s tips must be distributed within that site. But the underlying principles behind how splits are decided, communicated and reviewed should be consistent across the group. One site might be bar-led, another rooms-led, a third fine dining; each will have legitimate reasons for a different split, but the framework producing those splits should look the same across the group.

An independent Troncmaster working across sites helps councils navigate local realities without sacrificing that group-wide consistency.

How an Independent Troncmaster can help

Tronc Council members need grounding in the basics: conflicts of interest, confidentiality, decision-making and record-keeping. That’s exactly where a competent independent Troncmaster pulls their weight: bringing the framework into the room, supporting the council through it, issuing the anonymised summary to staff, and making sure every decision is documented in a way that holds up.

Whether the route is a Tronc council, a direct staff survey, the Troncmaster brings the structure, the independence and the audit trail that makes any consultation defensible. Good Troncmaster software can automate the direct consultation route end-to-end, with consultation design, distribution, response collection, anonymisation and summary generation all handled in one place, so the process is efficient and compliant for businesses of any size.

An independent Troncmaster will help you identify which consultation route works best for your business and run it properly.

The real test

A Tronc council can look like a lot of work up front. In practice, with the right people in the room and an independent Troncmaster to help, it becomes one of the simpler levers a hospitality business has for trust, retention and fairness. The same is true of direct staff consultation: with good Troncmaster software, the whole process from survey to anonymised summary is straightforward, scalable and fully audit-ready, whatever the size of your operation. The operators who get there before October won’t be scrambling to comply, they’ll already be running the kind of Tronc staff want to stay for. That’s the difference between an asset and a liability.